Pros and Cons of Loyalty Programs: An Honest Small Business Guide

Every loyalty programme guide on the internet will tell you that loyalty programmes are great. This one is going to tell you the truth: they're great when they're done right, and they can be a waste of money when they're not.

If you're considering a loyalty programme for your business, you deserve an honest assessment — not a sales pitch dressed up as advice. This guide covers the genuine advantages and real disadvantages of running a loyalty programme, with specific guidance on how to maximise the pros and avoid the cons. By the end, you'll know whether a programme makes sense for your business, and exactly what to watch out for if you launch one.

The Pros

1. You gain a direct communication channel with your customers

This is the most underrated advantage of a loyalty programme, and it's the one that generates the most revenue.

Without a loyalty programme, you have no reliable way to reach your customers between visits. Social media algorithms limit who sees your posts. Email open rates for small businesses hover around 15–20%. Flyers get binned. You're essentially hoping that customers remember you exist — which is a poor strategy in a world of infinite distractions.

A digital loyalty programme gives you push notifications — messages that land on your customers' phone lock screens with open rates between 40% and 60%. This is a communication channel you own and control, with no algorithm filtering and no per-message cost. The difference between a loyalty programme that passively collects stamps and one that actively drives revenue almost always comes down to how effectively you use push notifications in your loyalty programme — they're the mechanism that turns a digital card into a direct line to your customer's pocket.

What this means in practice: you can fill quiet days with a "double stamps today" message. You can recover drifting customers with an automated "we miss you" reminder. You can announce new products, seasonal offers, or limited-time promotions and know they'll actually be seen.

With Perkstar, push notifications are unlimited on every plan. The ability to reach your entire customer base instantly, for free, whenever you want, is a capability that most small businesses have never had — and it changes how you operate.

2. You increase visit frequency without increasing marketing spend

The core financial case for a loyalty programme: it generates repeat visits from existing customers, which costs dramatically less than acquiring new ones.

The maths are straightforward. If you spend £200 per month on marketing to attract 30 new customers, that's £6.67 per customer. A loyalty programme at £15 per month that motivates 25 existing customers to visit one additional time each generates 25 incremental visits at 60p each. The cost-per-visit comparison is roughly ten to one in favour of retention.

Beyond the direct cost comparison, repeat customers spend more per visit than new ones, refer friends without being asked, and are less price-sensitive. Every pound invested in retention generates a higher return than the equivalent pound spent on acquisition — and the gap widens the longer the programme runs, because your membership base grows while the subscription cost stays flat.

3. You get customer data that informs business decisions

A paper loyalty card tells you nothing. A digital loyalty programme tells you who your customers are, how often they visit, when they visit, how their frequency is trending, and which ones are at risk of leaving.

This isn't data for data's sake. It's practical intelligence that shapes decisions:

Your analytics show that Tuesday is your quietest day. You launch a "Double Stamp Tuesday" promotion. Tuesday traffic increases by 20%. You can see the cause and effect directly.

You notice that 12 members haven't visited in over three weeks. An automated lapsed-customer notification triggers. Five of them return within the week — customers you would have lost silently without the data to identify them and the channel to reach them. Businesses that treat loyalty analytics as a growth tool rather than a reporting afterthought consistently make faster, more confident decisions — because they're reacting to what customers actually do, not what they assume customers do.

Your redemption rate sits at 18%. You lower the stamp threshold from 12 to 8. Redemptions increase to 35%. The data told you the programme needed adjustment, and the platform let you adjust it in minutes.

For small businesses that have historically operated on intuition and guesswork, even basic loyalty data is transformative.

4. You build a competitive advantage in your local market

Every customer who's engaged with your loyalty programme is a customer your competitors are less likely to attract. Not through lock-in — through genuine value.

A customer with five stamps on your card, a birthday reward coming next month, and a push notification about your new seasonal offering has three active reasons to choose you over the alternative. A competitor without a programme is offering... proximity and product quality. Both of those matter, but they're easier to match than a structured loyalty relationship. For local businesses in particular, this advantage is amplified because the true value of a loyalty programme extends beyond transactions — it gives structure to the community relationships that chains can never replicate.

This advantage compounds over time. As your membership base grows, more of the local market's disposable spending flows through your programme. Competitors without one have no equivalent pull — meaning your programme isn't just retaining your customers, it's making it structurally harder for competitors to take them.

5. You create a referral and review engine

A well-designed loyalty programme doesn't just retain customers — it turns them into active promoters.

Perkstar's referral programme gives each member a unique link to share. When a friend signs up, both parties earn a reward. This converts natural word of mouth (which happens sporadically) into a structured system (which happens consistently). Setting up the mechanics — choosing reward timing, configuring bonus stamps, and enabling sharing links — takes minutes when you configure your referral programme through the dashboard, which means the system can be live before your next opening shift. Referral-acquired customers cost a fraction of advertising-acquired ones and arrive with pre-existing trust.

Google Review Rewards prompt members to leave reviews and reward them with bonus points. This builds your online reputation steadily — improving local search visibility and providing permanent social proof that works for your business 24/7.

Neither of these is possible with a paper punch card or a cash-register discount. They're capabilities that emerge specifically from having a digital loyalty platform — and they generate value beyond retention.

The Cons (And How to Avoid Each One)

Being honest about the disadvantages matters more than cataloguing the advantages. Here are the real risks of running a loyalty programme — and the specific steps that prevent each one.

1. A poorly designed reward can cost more than it generates

This is the most commonly cited risk, and it's real. If your reward is too generous relative to the revenue it generates, the programme loses money.

How it happens: A business offers a high-value reward (a free main course, a free full service, a large percentage discount) after too few visits. The reward cost exceeds the profit margin on those visits. Every redemption subtracts from the bottom line rather than adding to it. Understanding the full cost of running a loyalty programme — not just the subscription fee but the reward liability per cycle — is what separates programmes that generate profit from ones that quietly erode it.

How to avoid it: Run the maths before you launch. Multiply your average transaction by the number of stamps or points required. Then divide the reward's cost (your actual cost, not the retail price) by that total. If the reward cost is under 5–7% of cycle revenue, you're in safe territory.

For example: 8 stamps × £4 average transaction = £32 revenue per cycle. A free coffee costing you 40p = 1.25% reward cost. Extremely sustainable. Even a free product worth £3 retail (costing you perhaps £1.50 in ingredients) = 4.7% reward cost. Still comfortable for most businesses.

The numbers almost always work in the business's favour — but you need to check them, not assume.

2. A complicated programme confuses and disengages customers

Complexity is the second most common programme killer. If your customers can't explain the programme in one sentence, it's too complicated — and complicated programmes have low engagement and low redemption rates.

How it happens: The business tries to be too clever. Multiple earning tiers, different point values for different products, rotating bonus categories, expiry dates with exceptions, spend thresholds that vary by day of the week. Each rule makes sense individually but collectively creates a programme that nobody understands. The underlying principle is that simplicity drives customer loyalty more reliably than sophistication — a programme customers can explain to a friend in five seconds will always outperform one that requires a FAQ page.

How to avoid it: One earning mechanic. One reward. Zero ambiguity. "Buy 8, get one free" or "Earn 1 point per £1, get £5 off at 100 points." That's all most businesses need. You can add sophistication later (milestone rewards, seasonal promotions, segmented communications) without complicating the core earn-and-redeem mechanic.

Perkstar's default card setup follows this principle. You choose a card type, set a threshold, define a reward, and launch. The programme can be explained to a customer in seconds — which is exactly what should happen at a busy counter.

3. The programme requires consistent staff participation

A loyalty programme lives or dies at the point of sale. If staff don't ask customers to join, sign-ups stall. If staff skip scanning when they're busy, stamps go unrecorded and customer motivation fades. If staff don't understand the programme, they can't explain it or promote it enthusiastically.

How it happens: The business owner launches the programme, trains the team once, and then assumes it runs itself. Over time, staff become inconsistent — asking some customers but not others, scanning during quiet periods but skipping during rushes. The programme becomes unreliable, and customers notice.

How to avoid it: Make the loyalty scan part of the transaction, not an add-on. It happens every time, with every customer, during every shift — as automatic as processing the payment. Set clear expectations with staff, track sign-up numbers weekly, and celebrate milestones. If the team sees that sign-ups matter to management, they'll make them matter too.

The scan itself takes 2–3 seconds with Perkstar's scanner app — fast enough that it doesn't slow down even the busiest service periods. The friction is minimal; the habit just needs to be established.

4. Without communication, the programme goes dormant

A loyalty programme that issues stamps but never sends a message is a passive tool — and passive tools produce passive results. The stamps accumulate, but the programme doesn't actively drive behaviour. Customers forget they're enrolled. Progress stalls. Redemption rates stay low.

How it happens: The business sets up the programme, configures the reward, and then never uses the communication features. No push notifications, no automated rewards, no birthday messages. The programme technically exists, but it's silent — which means it's invisible between visits. The programmes that stay active share a common trait: the owner built a loyalty marketing plan with clear elements — a scheduled cadence of messages, automated triggers for key moments, and a simple content calendar that takes ten minutes a week to maintain.

How to avoid it: Schedule a minimum of one push notification per week. Configure three automations on day one: birthday rewards, lapsed-customer reminders, and reward-ready alerts. These take 15 minutes to set up and run indefinitely. The communication is what transforms a passive stamp card into an active retention system.

5. Not every business type benefits equally

This is the con that most loyalty guides won't mention: loyalty programmes work best for businesses with frequent, repeatable transactions. Cafés, salons, barbers, bakeries, restaurants, retail shops, fitness studios — these are ideal. The customer visits regularly, the transaction is similar each time, and the programme creates a natural earn-and-redeem rhythm.

Businesses with infrequent, high-value transactions (a kitchen fitter, an estate agent, a wedding planner) benefit less from a traditional loyalty programme because the visit cycle is too long for stamps or points to feel relevant.

How to assess: If your typical customer visits at least once a month, a loyalty programme will work. If they visit once a year or less, the traditional stamp/points model isn't the right fit — though membership or VIP programmes might be.

Real-World Example: What the Pros and Cons Look Like in Practice

An independent hair salon launches a Perkstar loyalty programme. Here's how the pros and cons played out over six months:

Pro — communication channel: The salon sends two push notifications per month. One promotional ("Book this week and earn double stamps"), one personal ("Happy birthday from the team!"). These messages generate an estimated 15–20 additional bookings per month that wouldn't have happened without the prompt.

Pro — visit frequency: Members visit an average of 5.2 times per year versus 3.8 for non-members. The programme is directly increasing how often customers return.

Con encountered — staff inconsistency: During months two and three, one stylist stopped asking new clients to join. Sign-ups dipped 40% on her working days. Once identified (through the analytics), the owner addressed it directly. Sign-ups recovered within a week. The data made the problem visible; without it, the drop would have continued unnoticed.

Con avoided — reward cost: The owner initially considered offering a free full cut and blow-dry (£45 retail) after 8 stamps. Running the maths: 8 visits × £45 average = £360 revenue, with a reward cost of approximately £15 (staff time + product) = 4.2% reward cost. Affordable — but she opted for a free treatment add-on (£15 value, £3 cost) as the standard reward with the full service as a milestone reward at 15 stamps. The salon's success came down to getting a handful of design decisions that make a loyalty programme great — a clear reward, consistent staff execution, and active use of the communication channel — rather than any single feature or promotion. This kept the core reward modest and the milestone aspirational.

Pro — referrals: The referral programme brought in 18 new clients over six months at zero advertising cost. These referral clients had a higher rebooking rate than advertising-acquired clients — because they arrived through personal recommendation.

Net result: The programme's advantages significantly outweighed its challenges. The one genuine con (staff inconsistency) was solvable. The potential con (unsustainable reward) was avoided through simple maths. Everything else was net positive.

Modern Take: Weighing Pros and Cons During a Cost of Living Crisis

The cost of living crisis has shifted the pro/con balance further in favour of loyalty programmes for small businesses.

On the pro side: customers are spending more deliberately and consolidating their spending with fewer businesses. A programme that rewards their loyalty gives them a financial reason to keep choosing you — and that reason carries more weight when every pound matters. In this environment, the businesses that thrive are the ones that retain customers and build brand loyalty through deliberate systems rather than hoping that a good product alone is enough to keep people coming back when budgets tighten.

On the con side: the pressure on margins means that getting the reward maths wrong is more punishing. An overly generous reward that was manageable during good times might not be sustainable when costs are rising and revenue is flat.

The net effect: loyalty programmes are more important than ever (because retention is the most cost-effective growth strategy during a downturn), but the design needs to be tighter. Get the threshold right, keep the reward sustainable, communicate consistently, and the programme becomes one of your most powerful tools for navigating economic pressure.

Getting Started

The pros of a well-designed loyalty programme — communication, retention, data, competitive advantage, and referrals — consistently outweigh the cons for businesses with regular customer transactions. The cons — unsustainable rewards, complexity, staff inconsistency, dormant communication, and poor business fit — are all avoidable with proper design and attention.

Perkstar makes the design straightforward: digital loyalty cards in Apple and Google Wallet, unlimited push notifications, automated rewards, referral programmes, Google Review Rewards, customer analytics, and a scanner app. Plans start at £15 per month with a free 14-day trial and no credit card required.

Start your free 14-day trial →